Understanding the Political Discourse on India’s Freedom Struggle: Implications for Europe-India Relations

Summary – Recent political statements in India revisiting historical narratives around the freedom struggle have potential reverberations for European diplomatic and economic engagements with India.,

Article –

Recent political statements in India have reignited debates regarding historical narratives about the country’s struggle for independence from British colonial rule. The Indian National Congress, a major political party, asserted that it and other ideological groups were instrumental in fighting for freedom, while criticising the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) for allegedly siding with the British colonial regime. These assertions come amid ongoing political contestations within India but also carry wider implications for Europe given the continent’s longstanding historical ties and growing strategic partnerships with India.

Background

The Indian independence movement, culminating in 1947 with the end of British colonial rule, involved a broad coalition of political and ideological groups. The Indian National Congress played a leading role in mobilising mass movements and negotiations to achieve independence. Conversely, the RSS, a right-wing Hindu nationalist organisation, has historically maintained a complex and sometimes controversial position towards colonial authorities. This recent public discourse undermines earlier narratives and revisits contentious interpretations of the past, reflecting current political polarisation within India. This renewed focus on historical legacies surfaces while India expands its international engagement, notably with European Union (EU) member states.

Key Players

The main stakeholders in this discourse include:

• Indian National Congress: Historically linked to the prominent leaders of the independence movement, it remains an influential albeit currently opposition political force in India.
• Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP): Closely associated with the RSS as its ideological parent organisation and currently leading the central government under Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
• RSS: Though not a political party, it significantly influences the ruling BJP’s policies and narratives.
• European actors: Including the European Commission, the European Parliament, and individual EU member governments that maintain multi-dimensional relationships with India, spanning trade, climate cooperation, and geopolitical strategy.

European Impact

The renewed politicisation of India’s freedom struggle history could influence Europe in several ways:

1. Bilateral Cultural and Academic Exchanges: European institutions often contribute to historical research and dialogue; differing narratives may challenge these collaborations.
2. Public Perception: European societies with diasporic ties to India may experience shifts influenced by these debates.
3. Economic Relations: India remains a significant trade and investment partner, but rising political polarisation could affect policy consistency, impacting confidence particularly in technology transfer, sustainable development, and joint innovation.

Wider Reactions

European bodies have approached the situation cautiously:

• The European Parliament and diplomatic missions emphasize non-interference while monitoring developments.
• Experts highlight the importance of contextualising India’s debates to preserve constructive dialogue on shared global challenges such as climate change and economic recovery.
• EU officials stress distinguishing internal political narratives from India’s strategic importance on the global stage.
• Adaptive diplomatic engagement and nuanced understanding are seen as essential for European policymakers.

What Comes Next?

The ongoing political discourse in India is expected to continue evolving, with implications for both domestic policies and international relations. Key future considerations for Europe include:

• Calibrated Engagement Strategies: Balancing respect for India’s sovereignty and political diversity with protection of shared interests.
• Support for Academic and Cultural Dialogue: Initiatives aimed at fostering mutual understanding about historical narratives.
• Continued Economic and Security Collaboration: Likely to proceed with heightened sensitivity to political changes.
• Adaptability: Leveraging multilateral forums and bilateral channels to maintain pragmatic partnership despite challenges.

As Europe deepens its ties with India amidst these shifting historical and political narratives, the long-term impact on cooperation and mutual perception remains an important area of observation.

About The Author