Fax and Furious: Why Germany Still Struggles to Go Digital

Despite Germany’s reputation for strong engineering and technology, the country faces significant challenges in digitalizing its public services. A notable reliance on outdated methods such as fax machines and paper documents has hindered progress, leaving Germany behind countries like Denmark and India in the digital government race.

One striking example of this lag is the continued use of fax machines by German public offices to handle official communications — a practice considered obsolete in the modern digital age. The COVID-19 pandemic further revealed the vulnerabilities of Germany’s digital infrastructure, highlighting difficulties citizens encountered when accessing government services remotely. Unlike Germany, other nations transitioned rapidly to efficient online platforms for public service delivery.

Reasons Behind Germany’s Digital Struggles

Experts attribute Germany’s slow digital transformation to several interconnected factors:

• Complex bureaucracy that slows decision-making and implementation.
• Strict data protection laws which impose tight regulations on digital innovations.
• The country’s federal structure divides responsibilities between national and regional governments, complicating a unified approach.
• Challenges related to funding and coordination, which have restricted investment in modern IT infrastructure for public services.

Contrast with Denmark and India

Denmark offers a successful model with streamlined online services in healthcare, taxation, and social affairs. Its advanced digital ID system enables secure and easy access to government services for citizens.

India, despite its vast size and diversity, launched the “Digital India” initiative. This program has driven widespread adoption of online government platforms and expanded financial inclusion across the country.

Steps Forward for Germany

Recognizing the urgency, Germany is taking concrete measures to improve its digital infrastructure:

1. Rolling out a new digital strategy focused on cybersecurity enhancements.
2. Expanding broadband access nationwide.
3. Improving digital skills among both the public and government officials.
4. Modernizing IT systems across federal and regional levels to deliver faster and more user-friendly services.

However, such transformative changes will take time before becoming apparent in everyday government interactions. Meanwhile, citizens and businesses continue to face delays and inefficiencies caused by antiquated administrative procedures.

Germany’s experience underscores that successful digital transformation demands not only technological upgrades but also significant organizational and political commitment.

About The Author