Italy’s Meloni Opposes France’s Move to Recognize State of Palestine Before Establishment

Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni has publicly opposed France’s recent decision to recognize Palestine as a state before its formal establishment. This position contrasts sharply with the announcement made by French President Emmanuel Macron at the United Nations earlier in April 2025.

Meloni’s Stance on Palestine Recognition

Speaking in Rome on April 27, 2025, Meloni stressed Italy’s preference for a diplomatic and negotiated approach to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. She argued that recognizing Palestine as a sovereign state without formal agreements between Israel and Palestinian authorities could hinder peace efforts. Meloni stated, “Recognizing a state before its actual establishment risks complicating peace efforts rather than supporting them.”

Contrasting Views: France vs Italy

At the recent UN General Assembly, President Emmanuel Macron announced France’s intention to acknowledge the State of Palestine. Macron believes this recognition supports the peace process and affirms Palestinian rights. However, Meloni and several other European Union members remain cautious, emphasizing diplomacy over premature recognition.

The Broader European and International Context

• Italy, along with other EU countries, prioritizes strengthening peace talks and regional stability.
• Several countries already recognize Palestine as an independent state, while others await negotiated outcomes.
• Italy advocates for a two-state solution – Israel and Palestine coexisting peacefully with secure borders.

Reasons Behind Italy’s Position

1. Maintain balanced relations with both Israel and EU partners.
2. Align with the broader EU policy focusing on negotiations for peace.
3. Avoid complications that premature recognition might bring to the peace process.

This divergence has sparked debates within Europe regarding the best way to support Middle East peace efforts. While France’s move is seen as bold by some, Italy’s cautious approach underscores the complexities involved in achieving lasting resolution.

For ongoing updates on this developing story, keep following Questiqa Europe News.

About The Author